BOY problem?

i need help. okay so theres a guy who i've liked since last year. he found out i liked him and he then started liking me also. he tried to ask me out before school ended but he got really shy and didnt. i didnt say anything either because i was really shy also..WE'RE BOTH REALLY SHY PEOPLE LOL. then summer came and we saw each other at the fair which was fun but that was the last time i got to see him until school came. okay now that school started, i met this other guy who likes me but i dont like him. the problem is that the guy i just met and the other guy who i've liked for a year are good friends. i dont want both of them to fight over me. i know that sounds conceited but thats the last thing i am. i really wish this wouldnt have to happen to me. UGHHH... so do you think i should forget them..even though it'll be hard for me but at least theyre not fighting and they can be happy??? ...oh and im not some middle schooler kid. im 16 lol